Good evening everyone, and here we are again, with yet another movie review. Tonight, we are going to be diving into a film that was in a group of animated films during the 1990s, known famously, or infamously as the “Disney knock-offs“. What do I mean by that term, you may ask? Well, as I’m sure most of us know, we had the period during the 1990s decade that was called the Disney Renaissance, that started with The Little Mermaid in 1989, and ended with Tarzan in 1999, as well as included other mostly great Disney films such as Beauty & The Beast, Aladdin, The Lion King, and films like those. However, what not nearly as many people likely know, unless you were a kid who grew up around the 90s, was that there were other companies such as MGM, Warner Bros., New Line Cinemas, and 20th Century Fox, for instance, that also came out with mostly lesser known animated films that, more often than not, tried a little too hard to act like the Disney films that were coming out around that time. Non-Disney animated movies that came out during this time included movies like Rock-A-Doodle, an animated remake of The King And I, The Pebble & The Penguin, Quest For Camelot, and tonight’s review, The Swan Princess. Sadly, most of these animated films that attempted to have a Disney kind of film were met with mostly mixed to negative reviews. Thankfully, there were at least a couple of these films, such as 1997’s Anastasia (made by 20th Century Fox), and 1998’s The Prince Of Egypt (made by Dreamworks), that got better reactions from critics, and audiences alike. With all that said, what is the Swan Princess, those of you who have never heard of it may ask? Well, it was an animated film that was released in theaters in 1994, just a few months after Disney’s highest grossing animated film, at the time, The Lion King. It was directed by a former animator at Disney named Richard Rich. Now, before we officially dive into the review, I’ll give you some background information about Richard Rich that I learned from other movie reviewers like Rachel Wagner, and Logan Ridenbaugh (aka Hewy Toonmore). Before starting his own animation company known as Rich Animation Studios, he helped direct Disney films like 1981’s The Fox & The Hound, as well as 1985’s The Black Cauldron. After that, Rich left Disney and formed his own animation company known as of course Rich Animation Studios. Not only did he direct The Swan Princess, but he also directed a few other animated films like Trumpet Of The Swan, The King & I, and I believe one or two other films. Interestingly enough, Rich also made his own set of animated Bible episodes that consisted of events from the Bible like Moses, Abraham & Isaac, The Death & Resurrection Of Christ, and others like those. Now, without further ado, let’s finally glide into the review of The Swan Princess.
Plot: Prince Derek (Howard McGillin), and his fiancé, Princess Odette (Michelle Nicastro speaking, and Liz Callaway singing voice) are pledged to be married and rule in Derek’s kingdom. But before this can happen, Odette gets abducted by an evil sorcerer named Sir Rothbart (Jack Palance), and her father, the king of his kingdom, along with some of his soldiers, are killed in the process. Rothbart then takes Odette to his castle, places a curse on her that turns her into a swan during the day, and human at night when the moon shines. Now, upon hearing this, can Derek find Odette, make a vow of everlasting love to her, and defeat the evil Rothbart once and for all?
Alright, so there were a couple reasons that I wanted to go ahead and revisit The Swan Princess around this time. One of them was that, a few years ago, my You Tube friend Rachel Wagner reviewed this film, and mentioned at one point during that review that she thought that this film was better than the 1998 Warner Bros. film Quest For Camelot. I then commented on that review, saying that I was basically surprised, and said that maybe I should rewatch both movies to see if I agreed, or disagreed with her on that. Which, that leads to my second reason. Upon hearing that the newer animated Scooby Doo movie, also made by Warner Bros., was originally gong to be released on May 15th of this year, when Quest For Camelot, and a Touchstone film named The Horse Whisperer (which I plan to finally watch sometime this year) turn twenty-two years old, I figured why not plan to watch Quest For Camelot around May or June of this year? Now, since Scoob is being delayed to likely later this year, due to the Coronavirus pushing some films from their original release dates to mostly later in this year, I’m debating whether or not to still watch Quest For Camelot sometime in May or June, or wait until it gets closer to the newer release date of Scoob. That is being played by ear as of right now. Anyway, my point is, I wanted to watch both Swan Princess and Quest For Camelot mostly to compare the two films.
Now that I’ve finally seeing this film again after so many years, does it still hold up even today? Well, in some ways, it’s sort of understandable as to why The Swan Princess became popular at least on video, and eventually turned into a franchise that consisted of a lot of direct-to-video sequels following the first movie’s theatrical debut. However, in others, one can argue that The Swan Princess might be a little overrated. First of all, about half to three quarters of the songs are little too sappy and strange. Okay, there were maybe one or two that were okay. However, the rest of the songs seemed rather pointless, and most of them may make you feel like they were inserted in there just for the sake of labeling this animated film as a musical, and/or even a Disney knock-off. It almost makes one wonder why this film didn’t just go the route of say Universal’s Balto (which came out a year after this film) and only have one or two songs, but have no songs after that, or better yet, no songs at all. Not only were most of the songs a little stupid, but even some of the characters were a little weird as well. Additionally, there were slightly too many characters, one or two of which seemed to be on the film just for the sake of pure comic relief, rather than serving as a better purpose to the plot. Okay, I’m not saying that comic relief characters are a bad thing by any means. However, if characters like that are going to likely make a distraction from the meat of the story, then that’s where it’s a little big of a problem, you know? Additionally, there were a couple plot holes in this film. There were also some of the jokes. Some of them were okay, but there were others that didn’t seem to make sense at least for the time period that this film was set in.
Luckily, however, unlike with 1996’s All Dogs Go To Heaven 2, there were at least a few more good things that came out of The Swan Princess. To begin, there was a very good message about learning to love others for their good qualities and values, and NOT just for their looks, or beauty, or things like that. Sure, that was done in the 1991 Disney movie Beauty & The Beast as well. Still, this movie did well with going more of a newer route with that message. There’s also some of the comedy. Granted, that may go with the whole deal about the jokes in this film. Still, one other thing to mention is that some of them would have worked a little better if some of those funny moments weren’t included in the mostly forgettable songs. As for the fact that this film wasn’t all that original, at least one can tell that The Swan Princess was trying to be very creative at times. But one of the biggest highlights of this film is the villain, Rothbart. Honestly, this guy could have maybe been taken out of this movie, and served as say a second-in-command to someone like perhaps the villain Malagant from the 1995 Columbia Pictures live-action film First Knight, or some movie like that. He’s developed well, he’s cold-hearted, and is not a bad guy that you want to piss off. As for the animation, while that’s not the best, it’s certainly okay at most. When you’re watching a film like this one, you can probably tell that you’re watching a movie that was directed by Richard Rich. He seems to have this style of animation that you can that when you watch this, or other works that he was involved in, you can probably tell that you’re watching one of Rich’s films. Finally, there’s the music by Lex de Azevedo. He seems to have this rather calm and peaceful type of music that can probably be distinguished very easily. There’s beautiful piano playing, and other factors that make Azevedo that make him stand out from other musicians, and/or other musical composers.
And that’s my review for The Swan Princess. Sure, it’s not quite one of the strongest animated movies. Still, if you’re flipping through On Demand, and you don’t care what you watch if it’s fault entertaining, then I guess you can’t go wrong with it. Well, feel free to give The Swan Princess a shot, and see what you think! And hey, on the brighter side, at least most of the non-Disney animated movies that were released after this one seemed to get somewhat better and better.
Final Grade: B-
P.S. Next up, Movie Review # 349, followed by the milestone of 350 reviews!