
Well, ladies and gentlemen, today, we are going to be reviewing a lesser known animated film that was released just a few months after Disney’s The Lion King back in the fall of 1994. Not only that, but some of you have heard if a former Disney animator named Don Bluth, yes? Well, just a recap, he apparently became dissatisfied with how the Disney animation company was handling making stories (or so the story goes), and, along with some other animators, left Disney to form their own animation company known as Don Bluth Studios, or something like that. Over the years since then, before 2000’s Titan A.E. ended up being the last full-length feature film that Bluth, be of course directed films like An American Tail, The Land Before Time, All Dogs Go To Heaven, Anastasia, and a few others. Well, while making animated films of his own, Don Bluth made an animated film that was/is said to be one of his worst animated films to date. Not only that, but it should also be noted that this is the last Don Bluth directed film to have Dom Deluise voicing a character, as well as Phillip Glasser, and Charles Nelson Reilly (the former, and latter playing in Don Bluth films An American Tail, and All Dogs Go To Heaven respectively). That being said, is today’s review one of Don Bluth’s worst films, or are critics, and maybe even audiences being too harsh on this film? Let’s find out by delving into my review of A Troll In Central Park.
Plot: Stanley (Dom Deluise) is a kind-hearted troll that lives in a troll kingdom, where flowers, and other plants are forbidden. However, when the evil troll queen, Gnorga (Cloris Leachman) , discovers that Stanley is secretly making, and planting flowers with his magical green thumb, she sends him to Central Park in New York, intent on exiling him to a place where “nothing grows,” not realizing that flowers, and other plants do in fact grow there too. After Stanley lands in New York, and eventually befriends two kids, Gus (Phillip Glasser), and his sister Rosie (Tawney Sunshine Glover), he learns to love life in Central Park. But when Gnorga, and her husband Llort (Charles Nelson Reilly) discover how happily content Stanley has become in his new environment, they make it their mission to find Stanley, and get rid of him once and for all. Can Stanley, and his new friends defeat King Llort, and Queen Gnorga before they succeed in using their magical powers in an attempt to turn Stanley into stone, and ridding the world of him?
I will say this, as I go into my review for this film. Before rewatching this movie recently, I will say that I remembered a few things from watching this film before as a kid. First, I remember that my first time seeing this film, if I recall correctly, was on the weekend of Mother’s Day 1995. That same weekend, my family, and I visited Cherry Hills Community Church in Highlands Ranch, CO. I was in kid’s church, and then got lost at one point, washing my hands over, and over again, for some odd reason. In the process, I made my parents such, and worried, to the point where one of them was grieved when they found me, and basically asked me not to do something like that again. Anyway, I also remember a some other firsts from that weekend, and seeing A Troll In Central Park. The second thing was, if I also recall correctly, hearing about trolls, and creative magical powers, like, in this film, the villain wanting to turn others into stone that got in her way. Oh, and there were a couple other firsts from at least watching this film for the first time. That being that I remember hearing the name Stanley for the first time. Yes, I would hear names like that, and Rosie, and Gus later on in life, but still. Finally, I remember hearing the word “coward” for the very first time in this film (yes, that is, due to one character calling another character a coward at one point in this film).
So, with all those being memorable aspects in my experience with A Troll In Central Park, does this film hold up today? Sadly, no! In fact, I can see why A Troll In Central Park is considered to be one of Don Bluth’s weakest films to date. To begin, this film may have either worked as a short film, or in a different setting. I do have another confession to make. When I first saw the 2002 Disney film Lilo & Stitch as a teenager, I felt like while the beginning of that film was strong, with there being aliens, and outer space, it started off strong. However, I felt like things went downhill when we met Lilo, and her older sister, Nani. Again, that was teenage me. About a decade later, I realized how much stronger the story of Lilo & Stitch was even after the very beginning, and realized the point more of why that film was made the way that it was. However, with A Troll In Central Park, I got a completely different feeling, for the most part. I felt as if the beginning was interesting, and had the potential for a good setup. However, when Stanley gets sent to Central Park in New York City, even as an adult, and as adults, I’m sure many of us. An agreement that once that happens, the story most definitely does go downhill, for the most part. That being said, there is so much filler in this film. If you can name me some of those moments that felt necessary for this film, please let me know! Also, seeing as this film has Don Bluth as the director for the film, the very same guy who directed The Secret Of NIMH, The Land Before Time, and some of those films? Wow, he sunk really low this time around. I’m not sure if Bluth was pressured to rush the production of this movie, or something else happened. Either way, as a result of whatever happened, A Troll In Central Park ended up squandering the potential to be a good, or even great film. I’m not sure if this film should have been set in a different time period, or the execution of the story just needed to be more interesting somehow, even if set in modern times. What’s more is that unlike the majority of other animated films that Don Bluth directed, the story for this one doesn’t feel even remotely as engaging, strong, or even interesting as most of his other films that he directed. Oh, and another thing! For those of you that just watched this film as kids, or even rewatched it recently, you know how there are a couple points, where Rosie, one of the kid characters, who is likely six months to a year old, gives Stanley a peck on the cheek, and Stanley either gets twitter patted by either going flying in the air, his ears slightly wiggling, or things like that? Okay, regardless of whether this film had been release in 1994, or 2000, or even in more recent years like 2016, or this year of 2022, that’s probably rather creepy, wouldn’t you say? Yeah, I get that Gus, and Rosie were the first humans that Stanley met upon arriving in New York City. Still, did we really need a scene, or scenes like those? Personally, I wouldn’t be surprised if scenes like those factored into this film performing poorly at the box office. For crying out loud, A Troll In Central Park didn’t even make $1,000,000 like many other films do. Additionally, the animation is just so so. There were points where the animation is really good when it is good. However, the animation almost looks like something that could have been drawn by a child around maybe 5-10 years old. The characters are also not that interesting! What’s more is that Gnorga, and Llort seem very similar to villains like Yzma and Kronk from The Emperor’s New Groove. Unlike Troll, however, at least New Groove had the male, and female villains written up much better, and were much more likable. As for the story overall, it feels like it was definitely an animated film made mostly for kids than for adults. Normally, that wouldn’t be an issue. But here’s the thing! Don Bluth had a track record of making very mature films, be it ones like The Secret Of NIMH, Titan A.E., and others like them. The same can’t be said for A Troll In Central Park, unfortunately. Finally, as far as cons go, none of the characters seem to change, and/or mature emotionally. Yes, characters, like Stanley, for instance, do get certain tasks done, whether reluctant to do so, or not. Even so, not even in Stanley do we not see much of character growth, or a character arc.
But are there good things in this film? Well, there are couple things. First off, having a villain that hates good things of the world seemed like a nice idea. It was also good to have some very nice messages about not being afraid to do what’s right as well. Oh, and there were a few funny parts throughout the film too.
And that’s my review for A Troll In Central Park. Yeah, after rewatching this film again, I can see why the film didn’t do well in theaters, is considered not all that good. The storyline isn’t that good, the characters are hardly interesting, and the film’s hardly even memorable. I would say only see this movie of you’re wanting to see an animated film for additional entertainment. Even then, only young kids will like this film, while adults may not be as fan of it. Or so may probably be the case.
Final Grade: D+








