
Alright, now, as I’m sure many of you know, this newer Disney animated film, known simply as Wish, was just released 5-6 weeks ago. At this point, you may be wondering why I’m finally getting to reviewing this film this many weeks later, following it’s release on Wednesday, November 22nd, 2023. Was it because I didn’t originally plan to see this Disney film after hearing reviews of it that leaned more towards the negative side than the positive one? Absolutely not! In fact, I still planned to see Wish, regardless of whether people were saying more good, bad, or even ambivalent things about it. However, because I was out of town during the time that it was first out around Thanksgiving time, and because I was either seeing other films afterwards, and things like that, it was more that I decided to go ahead, and just see this film closer to Christmas time. In this case, I finally did see Disney’s Wish a couple times already, once a couple weeks before Christmas Day, and another time shortly after that holiday. So now that I’ve finally seen it, let’s discuss Disney’s 62nd Animated Feature, Wish, which stars Ariana DeBose, Chris Pine, Alan Tudyk, Victor Garber, and a few other actors, and actresses.
Plot: In the fictional Kingdom Of Rosas, King Magnifico (Chris Pine) grants wishes to the the citizens of his kingdom once a year. But when a young teenage girl named Asha (Ariana DeBose) discovers a secret corruption in regards to the King, and his Kingdom, it is up to her, with the help of human friends of hers, a star from the sky named Star, and a goat named Valentino (Alan Tudyk) to deal with the agenda, and put Rosas in a better position than it was before.
Well, now that I’ve seen Disney’s latest animated film a few weeks after it was first released, you may be wondering, is this film as bad as a lot of people are saying it is? Well, let me put it to you all this way! Wish wasn’t exactly a horrible film, but it wasn’t one of Disney’s best works either. So, allow me to elaborate! This time around, I think I’ll have the negatives, and positives in one paragraph, simply because a lot of elements for this film, I think a lot of people that see this film will have mixed elements on. For those of you that have seen this film already, and disagree, let’s have a peaceful discussion about that. Anyway, on with the review!
First off, let’s start off with the character development. Okay, the character development could have improved. Let’s start off with the main character herself, Asha. Well, she was an alright character for the way that she was written. Don’t get me wrong. There are for sure some good qualities to her, such as the fact that she’s selfless in terms of wanting to give other people’s wishes a chance, especially those in her family. She also is willing to go to great risks to accomplish what she needs to. Also, how could we not like her solo I want song, “This Wish”? Honestly, though it may not win, hopefully it will at least get nominated. The thing about this song is that, though Asha may be singing about wanting certain goals for herself, she sings, and shows in the song that she cares more about the possible best interest of her kingdom of Rosas. Don’t believe me? Well, listen to the song, and you’ll likely know, and understand what I mean. Still, I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of people would have mixed feelings about how she was written, and/or how she handled situations throughout the course of this film. As for the side characters, hardly any of them, aside from the goat, Valentino, and Asha’s best friend, Dahlia, who looks sort of like Snow White, hardly are interesting at all. So, Asha has seven human friends that are supposed to basically serve as the side characters, and/or comic relief, in addition to Valentino, and Star. Sadly, none of them seem to have that much development, again, with the exception of Dahlia, and don’t seem to shine as well as they could have. As I was watching Wish, I remember finding myself comparing them to say the Seven Dwarves from the 1937 Disney film, Snow White & The Seven Dwarves, or even the lesser known six side characters from the 2001 Disney animated film, Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Granted the side characters from Atlantis weren’t quite as memorable as at least the dwarves, but they were still memorable, and likable, which is more than can be said about these newer side characters from Wish. Oh, and one more thing! The way that some of the side characters were written, and how some character arcs were handled with some of them, it felt rushed, and kind of out of place. Then, there’s the villain, King Magnifico. Okay, Disney seemed to write him as this supposed complex villain who thinks he’s doing good, but turns out that he isn’t. Oh my gosh! His character was done so much better in older Disney films like with Frollo in 1996’s Hunchback Of Notre Dame, or even someone like Kron from 2000’s Dinosaur. But with Magnifico, as you watch this film, let’s just say that you could potentially find yourself cheering for him, and feeling sorry for him more than Asha. Yeah, when you feel more sorry for a villain than your hero, or heroine, that’s kind of tragic, wouldn’t you say? Finally, that leads to my final character, Asha. Again, she is a fun character, and one must give her credit for her compassionate nature, caring for those around her, and more. Still, her character could have probably maybe been written better, and her potentially having a better character arc than she seemed to have in the end. Next, there’s the storyline overall. Okay, I heard that in earlier drafts, both the King, and Queen were going to be a villain duo, and the star character was going to be a human, and star character named Starboy, who would basically serve as a love interest for Asha, among other things that made it sound like this film would have been stronger than it was in the end. Okay, am I saying that it’s bad that both the King, and Queen weren’t villains. Well, it was certainly a nice change to have only one of them be villains. Still, with this being a fairytale, maybe this film would have been stronger. You got me! Also, with the whole Starboy, and Asha deal, especially since one of the songs, by the name of “At All Costs” seemed to sound more like a love ballad between those two, and then changed to being used for something entirely different, and for a rather stupid reason, in the final version of this film, yeah, that’s another reason why the writing for this Disney film wasn’t all that great. Okay, the writing did have its strong points. Still, the weaker points seemed to outweigh the stronger ones in this case. And one other thing regarding the original Asha, and Starboy deal! Is Disney really afraid to have a main character have a love interest? Don’t get me wrong! It is nice that Disney is diverting from the romantic happily ever after in more recent years. Still, is it really wrong for Disney to have a love relationship between a male, and female character as of nowadays? Just wondering! With that said, what’s even more is that likely because of the fact that this Disney film was commemorating Disney’s 100th anniversary, Disney seemed to rush this film, and cared more about making callbacks, Easter eggs, and references to previous Disney films than making a good story overall. Honestly, if Disney had just cared more about making a good story than about these callbacks, references, and things like that, then that’s another reason this film could have been better than it was in the end. Well, hopefully Disney learned their lesson after this one to not rush their films, animated, or live-action, because of a special occasion, or things like that. Time will tell. Next, there’s the animation for this film. First of all, what Disney was trying to do when mixing 3D, and 2D animation, that was most definitely an intriguing move on their part. Did it work in the end? Well, yes, and no. Here’s the thing. The visuals were phenomenal, particularly during numbers like “I’m A Star”, and “Knowing What I Know Now.” And, again, the 2D, and 3D mix was a nice idea. Not to mention having callbacks to older films like with Snow White & The Seven Dwarves, or even other films like The Little Mermaid, Aladdin, and even using the storybook to tell a story. At other times, however, like during songs such as “This Wish,” the animation kind of felt like something that could be out of a video game like one of the Mario games, or maybe one of the Zelda ones, or games like those. As a result, the animation could have been better, and improved. Next, there are the numbers for this film. Well, though they won’t be impactful like many other songs of Walt Disney Animation Studios’ features, they were still simple, and fun, including ones like “Kingdom Of Rosas”, and “At All Costs”, and ones that you might find yourself humming to like “This Wish”, “I’m A Star”, “Knowing What I Know Now”, and the villain song, “This Is The Thanks I Get.” For the last one, it was more upbeat than an actual villain song. I would say that if there was ever a time when there was a Category for Best Villain Song, and this past year was one of those years, “Good To Be King” from Journey To Bethlehem would have been the one I would have voted for. Don’t get me wrong, “This Is The Thanks I Get” was still fun, and even hilarious at times. Still, if people were to say what would be a potential more memorable, and richer song, the one from Journey To Bethlehem would probably sound cooler, and better. Still, it was nice to have a villain song from a Disney animated film in over a decade. Oh, and did I forget to mention the reprise of “This Wish” that occurs near the end of this film? I won’t go into details as to why it occurs, but let’s just say that hearing Asha sing, and nearly every other character sing it, and having it sound like an actual choir, wow, most definitely one of the major highlights when it comes to the songs in this film. Oh, and the choreography in some of the songs was really great as well. One other thing to mention in regard to the songs is that the instruments, and choreography that were used throughout this film were amazing. Finally, the messages in this film can come off as a mixed bag, and possible even convoluted. I mean it’s good to have dreams, and wishes. But seeing as this film seemed to depict the message that it could potentially be wrong for some to not be granted, that was definitely not the best part of this film. Like nearly everything else, the messages of this movie can be both good, and bad-sided at the same time.
And that’s my review for Disney’s 62nd animated feature, Wish. I’m not sure if it was due to there being a change in leadership over the past few years, Disney rushing this film since the company reached it’s 100th anniversary, or even a combination of them both, and more. Either way, Wish was decent, but still had some potential to improve. I would say that since John Lasseter was let go as head of Pixar, and Walt Disney Animation Studios a few years ago, the company slowly, but surely seemed to go downhill in their quality of storytelling. Not just Lasseter, but maybe even change in the creative team overall. With all that said, hopefully Disney will learn their lesson from what went wrong with Disney’s Wish, and will improve in quality of storytelling in the future. With Wish flopping, Disney needs to learn that rushing projects is never a good idea, being political, and/or woke is never the way to go, and lessons like those. No, Wish didn’t feel so woke aside from the messages of this film feeling rather mixed, and convoluted. Still, the messages can come off as not being the best. I would say that if you really want to see Wish, then just see it for free at the movie theater, or wait for the film to arrive on Disney+ in a few months. So now that I’ve reviewed Wish, let me tell you to go ahead, and see it, and see what you think! One more thing! When the credits roll, please do not leave the theater, or stop the movie yet. There are drawings that are scattered throughout the movie that will serve as callbacks to older Disney animated films, as well as a post credit scene that you definitely don’t want to miss for a reason that I won’t give away to avoid spoilers. So, after watching Wish, please watch the credits, and stick to the very end, when the post credit scene occurs.
Final Grade: C+








